Book Review: Beneath a Scarlet Sky by Mark Sullivan

World War II Italy is the setting for Beneath a Scarlet Sky, an engrossing novel based on the wartime experiences of teenager Pino Lella. Although it’s based on actual events, it reads like a thriller that has a lot of suspense and a lot of heart.

This post may contain Amazon Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you, from qualifying purchases. (This in no way affects the honesty of my reviews!) All commissions will be donated to the ALS Association.

First, a quick summary of Beneath a Scarlet Sky:

Seventeen-year-old Pino lived in Milan. He was a typical teenage boy, running around with his friends and hoping to land a girlfriend. For the first few years of the war, he was pretty insulated from its more devastating effects, but that all changed in the summer of 1943, when Allied forces began bombing Milan. When the bombing persisted and hit too close to home, Pino’s parents sent him to a boys’ camp high in the Alps that was run by a Catholic priest named Father Re. They thought he would be out of harm’s way there.

It turned out that camp in the Alps was part of the Catholic Underground, which helped Jews escape across the Alps into neutral Switzerland. Father Re immediately recruited Pino to act as a guide to lead groups of Jews to safety. Pino turns out to be extremely resourceful and capable as he leads ordinary people (ie, not mountain climbers) across rugged terrain in sometimes terrible weather conditions.

Father Re and his group risked imprisonment or execution for helping Jews escape the Nazis. They’re an example of people who act heroically and with compassion when faced with an adverse situation. While in the Alps, Pino also encountered the exact opposite in the form of a band of men who masqueraded as resistance fighters but were really just lawless, violent thugs. In the chaos of war, when the normal enforcement of laws is disrupted, the baser, uncivilized nature of some people is unleashed. It’s a grim reminder of why we need laws and law enforcement. This theme of good versus bad human nature and behavior is a theme throughout the rest of the book.

Shortly before his 18th birthday, Pino’s parents summon him back to Milan. At 18, he will have to join the military. If he waits to be drafted by the Italian army, he will likely have to go to the Russian front. No one wants to go to the Russian front, right? His other option is to join the German army and use family connections to get an assignment in Milan. So his choices were the Russian front or don a Nazi uniform. Can you imagine having to make that choice? He chooses the latter.

By a twist of fate, he is chosen to be the driver of the Nazi general who is in charge of construction and engineering in Italy. It makes Pino privvy to a lot of sensitive German intelligence, which he passes along to the Italian resistance. Pino is exposed to things that are remarkable, devastating and haunting. He meets Mussolini. He witnesses the inhumanity of forced labor crews (slaves). And he sees cruel, shocking violence.

Pino’s personal life is greatly affected by the war. He hates working for the Nazis and some of his friends and family hate him for it, too. He longs to tell them he’s a spy but instead he has to endure their loathing. In addition, several people in his life are killed, typically in brutal and senseless acts. He does find love and that’s one of the few bright things in his war experience.

Pino’s adventures in the Alps and as a driver for the general are entertaining, hair-raising and sometimes bleak and bluntly violent. Pino himself is impressive and resourceful and has a lot of heart. The author of Beneath a Scarlet Sky covers a great breadth of important topics about the war – the despicable behavior of Nazis and fascists, the persecution of Jews and political dissenters, the helpless suffering of civilians, the heroism of otherwise ordinary people, the frightening brutality of angry mobs. History is important to know and with Beneath a Scarlet Sky, Mark Sullivan has created a work that is both entertaining and educational and should appeal to teenagers and adults. I’m definitely going to encourage my high schoolers to read it (or at least see the movie – release date tbd).

Overall, Beneath a Scarlet Sky is an excellent book! I highly recommend it.

Beneath a Scarlet Sky is March’s discussion book. Don’t be shy! Share your opinion below in the comments section.

5 thoughts on “Book Review: Beneath a Scarlet Sky by Mark Sullivan

  1. Hi Michelle! Robin Paradise here. I just recently joined your blog – and love to see your reviews! I truly appreciate your thoughtful insights and recommendations – I’m getting this book tonight! You have been in my thoughts and prayers–as one of my ND role models and the journey you have traveled since then. We just saw George and Molly a few weeks ago and were fondly remembering you and all of our ND days. Wishing you a blessed and Happy Easter! Can’t wait for the next review!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you, Michelle, for putting another WWII historical novel on your book club list! This has become one of my favorite genres and I had yet to read a story with an Italian perspective. I think I enjoy reading about this particular time era because in reality it was not that long before I was born. It is so hard to imagine the horrendous attrocities that occurred in what we believed to be “civilized” countries. Beneath a Scarlet Sky shows how quickly the youth of that era had to grow up. Their challenges were so enormous and I am sure I couldn’t perform as bravely as young Pino.

    When driving along mountainous roads or hiking/biking narrow single-track trails, I am usually very anxious. I’ve been thinking about that climb and trail through the alps, telling myself, “This is a piece of cake next to Pino’s journey!”

    Can’t wait to hear your next selection!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: 12 Months of Reading Goodness | Book Thoughts from Bed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.