Book Review: To the Hilt by Dick Francis

I haven’t read any Dick Francis since I was a teenager. At the time, I loved mysteries and horses, so his novels hit a sweet spot for me. Recently, my brother-in-law gifted me with To the Hilt (thanks, Stephen!), and it was fun rediscovering Dick Francis. While it didn’t contain a clever, twisty whodunit plot, To the Hilt was enjoyable reading.

The protagonist is Alexander Kinloch, son of aristocracy who chooses to live off the grid in Scotland so he can paint. He’s considered to be the eccentric member of the family, but it turns out he also has a strong sense of duty and a pretty practical head on his shoulders. When his stepfather falls ill, his mother summons him to London to help take care of her husband’s business, a brewery.

The brewery’s head of finance recently embezzled millions, leaving the business in dire straits. Alexander has to deal with this while fending off a hostile step sister and violent thugs. The former thinks Alexander wants to steal her inheritance while the latter think he’s hiding something of value and try to beat the location out of him.

Alexander has a reputation for being good at hiding things and, in fact, he is hiding some valuables, including family heirlooms and his stepfather’s racehorse. This all plays into the plot as Alexander tries to track down the brewery’s lost money. Fortunately, he has a quirky PI/master of disguise to help out and watch his back.

The characters were probably the best thing about To the Hilt. Alexander was eccentric but in a very likable way. The PI was amusing without being over the top and his interactions with Alexander were funny. And then there were numerous relatives – an aristocratic uncle with shades of Scottish chieftain, a mother with severely repressed emotions, a strong estranged wife – all done well.

The plot was engaging, but not in a classic mystery way. There was some periodic excitement and suspense, although mostly it was just an interesting story told with heart and humor. I liked it.

Thanks for the recommendation, Stephen!

Reminder – if you’re participating in the 2020 Thoughtful Reading Challenge, March’s challenge is to read a mystery novel. I’m hoping to finish Agatha Christie’s Death on the Nile by the end of the month so I can tell you all about it. So far, it’s really good!

One thought on “Book Review: To the Hilt by Dick Francis

  1. Glad you managed to read while working on your project this month. I will have to try Dick Francis again. It has been a while. My mysteries this month have been Dead Simple by Peter James (were you the one who recommended him recently?) and Someone Knows by Lisa Scottiline. I have never read James before and really liked this first mystery in his series. It was much, much better than any others I have read in the last year. Good characters, somewhat believable events and some good plot twists at the end. I will keep reading the series. Lisa Scottiline is an author I have read and enjoyed before and I just saw her speak with her daughter (also an author) at an Author’s Week in Fernandina Beach. Great talk as Scottiline is a very genuine and interesting person. However, that said, I actually really disliked “Someone Knows.” I almost did not finish it. The characters were not believable or likeable and the “mystery” was not really a mystery nor suspenseful. When I went to add it to Goodreads, my daughter’s review popped up: “Do not read. Awful.” Guess I should have talked to her first. Anyway, great review of “To The Hilt.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.