Book Review: Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil by John Berendt

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil was published in 1994 and spent four years on the New York Times bestseller list. How am I just now reading it?!? True-ish crime that is pure entertainment gold.

I say “true-ish” because the author admits he took some liberties with the timeline and I’m going to hazard a guess and say he did the same with the very long dialog passages. Once I came to terms that I wasn’t reading straight-up nonfiction, I could sit back and enjoy the show.

And what a show it was!

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil is about a murder that takes place in Savannah, Georgia in 1981. But I wouldn’t even say the murder is the star of the show. Sharing the stage on equal footing are the city of Savannah and the eccentrics who thrive in the isolated, historic, genteel and very Southern city.

The author began traveling to Savannah on a fluke. He was living in New York City when he realized that for the price of a nice dinner, he could instead fly to different destinations for weekend trips. One of these trips was to Savannah and he became hooked, eventually spending more time in Savannah than NYC. Because he was a Yankee and writer, he was a novelty and a lot of doors were open to him.

And he took full advantage of these open doors, experiencing some highly entertaining events and meeting some truly unique people. These people included a flamboyant drag queen, a voodoo priestess, a career scam artist, and many members of Savannah’s upper crust. He attended murder trials, an all black cotillion where debutantes danced a minuet, the Christmas party all of Savannah society wanted to attend, and a midnight voodoo ritual in a cemetery.

The author seemed to relish all these escapades as well as the people involved, and it showed in his writing. Never judgmental, John Berendt’s writing was pitch perfect. The descriptions of Savannah’s architecture, history, and character were so vivid that I found myself wanting to travel there for a long visit. I can’t say I’d want to meet all the characters (some were just too quirky for me!), but the author did a terrific job developing them through descriptions, dialog, and some anecdotal history about them.

Historic Savannah architecture is featured prominently in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil

Two of these characters were Jim Williams and Danny Hansford. Jim was a gay antiques dealer who lived in one of the city’s finest houses and clawed his way into Savannah’s upper crust. Danny was a young, volatile, redneck hustler who worked his way into Jim Williams’ household. Late one night, Jim shoots and kills Danny. Was it murder or self-defense? That is the question that FOUR different juries try to figure out. Yes, due to a combination of appeals and one hung jury, Jim Williams was tried for murder four times over ~8 years. Four trials could have been tedious to read about, but the author distills the details down to just what we need to know. And he uses the opportunity to slowly pull back the curtain on Jim Williams’ character, and we find a lot of haughty emptiness.

I’m not going to tell you the outcome of the fourth trial because, really, you should read this book yourself (if you’re one of the dozen people who hasn’t read it yet). Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil isn’t just for true crime or nonfiction enthusiasts. Fiction readers who love eccentric characters and great story telling should enjoy it, as well. I enthusiastically recommend it!

OK, I know some of you must have read Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil and I really want to know your thoughts. Did it inspire you to visit Savannah? Did you Google any of the characters or houses? Have you seen the movie?

12 thoughts on “Book Review: Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil by John Berendt

  1. I read Midnight many years ago. I no longer remember the plot or the characters, but I can still vividly recall the dark, damp, verdant mood of the locale. I haven’t gotten to Savannah yet, but I somehow feel like I’ve visited through this great book. Thanks for the reminder!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I did read this in the 90’s and LOVED it! We even visited Savannah on a vacation. The characters are amazing. I have to add that I excited went to the movies to see it when it came out. I was sorely disappointed. The movie bored me. For anyone who saw the movie-don’t let it keep you from reading the book.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Living in Savannah from 1993-1996, we were there when this book came out. Obviously, it got great notoriety and became required reading for people like us who were new to the the area. It has been since1995ish that I read this book so I too don’t remember a lot of the details but I do remember that I was lukewarm on it. Too quirky for my tastes? I’m glad you enjoyed it so much and maybe I should consider giving it another look.


  4. Pingback: The 2023 Thoughtful Reading Challenge | Book Thoughts from Bed

Leave a Reply to Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.